I grew up in old homes where character and charm were simply part of daily life. The moulding, the antique doorknobs, the creak of the floors, the path worn into the stairs — it’s the little details that make the biggest different, yet it’s also easy to take those things for granted when you live it everyday.
When I sold my first home — a darling 1920s bungalow with its own unique features and quirks — and bought an 8-year-old new build in a development where the same four floor plans were copy & pasted, I quickly realized that in my trade for condition, location and price, I had sacrificed all the elements that I believe truly transform a house into a home. It took me a long time to realize that, what makes a home feel lived-in is the layers. Those tiny, often overlooked details that give a space a point of view. But the good news? Almost all of them can be added in, no matter how new or builder-basic the house you’re starting with.
Paint
Photos from Pinterest
By far, the easiest (and most affordable!) way to add character to any space is with a fresh coat of paint. Over the years, I’ve gone through my fair share of trendy color choices, but I’m partial now to creamy whites that allow me to create a neutral base and swap a seasonal palette of decor throughout the year. My favorite color options are Benjamin Moore’s Swiss Coffee and Sherwin Williams Alabaster.
PRO TIP: Get a high-quality 2” angle brush—this one is my personal favorite—and you’ll never need to tape again.
Paper & Wall Moulding
Photos from Pinterest
Alternatively, wallpaper can add a punch, especially when papering a small space. I love the unexpected pop of pattern, texture, and color in places like closets or half-baths.
When appropriate, applied moulding gets you a similar sense of age and craftsmanship. The options are endless with picture frame moulding, board and batten, or a simple rail.
Swap Outlet & Switch Plates
Photos from Pinterest
Replace those plastic outlet & switch plates with ones that provide a bit more pizzazz. It’s a small enough swap that you can knock out an entire house in a weekend, but it’s also one of those details guests notice without being able to say exactly why the room feels different.
This is also an instance where less is more. I’d focus attention on swapping out those more visual elements—for example: the switch plates when you enter a room—rather than replace every outlet plate hidden behind furniture.
Add or Change Knobs & Pulls on Cabinetry
Photos from Pinterest
Personally, I love the look and feel that unlacquered metal provides. As it ages, it adds such warmth and patina to the space and, with more and more use, weathers the testament of time. Like Clooney, unlacquered hardware gets better with age instead of just looking dated. Every fingerprint and water spot is proof that the space is being lived in and loved.
DESIGN TIP: a mix of metals and styles (using knobs and pulls) breaks up the wall of cabinets and gives the space some visual rhythm instead of reading as one flat block. And because the swap is purely cosmetic, it’s one of the easiest projects to take with you if you ever move — pull the builder-grade hardware, box it up, and take your real knobs to the next house.
Change Floor & Wall Register Covers
Photos from Pinterest
Who says your walls and floor vent covers need to stay basic? These are some of the most overlooked spots in a home, and swapping the standard builder-grade grate for cast metal or a decorative pattern is such an easy way to sneak old-house detail into a new build.
They’re also one of the few details in this list that were genuinely decorative even in the era they’re mimicking: old homes used ornate cast iron registers because they were visible, functional pieces of the room, not something to hide. A brushed brass or aged bronze cover in a hallway or at the base of a staircase does the same work now, and because most register covers are a standard size, it’s one of the more affordable swaps here too.
Replace Door Handles, Hinges & Door Stops
Photos from Pinterest
Swapping the standard lever or knob for something with real weight to it such as an aged brass egg knob, a black iron mortise set, or crystal glass changes the way a door feels every single time you touch it. Don’t stop at the handles, either. Hinges and door stops are usually an afterthought, but a decorative hinge, magnetic door stopper or a simple brass acorn stopper is the kind of detail that makes a hallway feel finished instead of builder-basic.
This is also one of the few swaps that have not only daily interaction, but also the most physical. Every single day, without even thinking about it, your hand is holding, twisting, and turning the same knobs that has born countless past lives and that’s such a cool element to add to the story of your own home.
Add Dust Corners to Stairs & Wall Corner Guards
Photos from Pinterest
These little darlings pull double-duty. Not only do they look cute and dress up the simplest of functional architecture in stairways, but they do a great job at keeping the dustballs from piling up. And, the wall corner guards are fantastic at protecting baseboards and drywall from the occasional vacuum cleaner ding.
Replace Light Fixtures
Photos from Pinterest
Swap out those builder-grade basic fixtures with ones that actually have a shape and a presence — an antique-inspired sconce, a fluted glass pendant, something with a little age to it even if it's brand new. Lighting is one of the fastest ways to make a room feel considered instead of default.
Tile
Photos from Pinterest
Tile is one of the few finishes that gets to be permanent or semi-permanent if using peel & stick, so it's worth treating it like an opportunity rather than an afterthought. When in doubt, lean into the classic styles: a hand-glazed subway tile, a small hex pattern in an entryway, or a bit of pattern on a backsplash can do more to age a space than almost anything else on this list.
Highlight What Exists
Photos from Pinterest
At the end of the day, it's crucial to remember that a contemporary build will never truly look or feel like a different era home, no matter what changes are made. Rather, it's important to also highlight the architecture you do have — the trim, the windows, the built-ins — and let those existing features do some of the work instead of fighting against them. For example, my current home has vaulted ceilings in the living and kitchen. I would never add picture moulding to the angled walls because it would just look weird. I would, however, add an aged & weathered wood beam to drawn attention to the vault.
Every house, even a brand-new one, has architectural bones worth working with rather than around. And remember: the goal is not to trick anyone into thinking this is a hundred-year-old house. It's to make sure the character & charm you add has something real to stand on.
SHOPPE MY FAVORITES
I hope this inspires you to think about new ways to make your house a home. If you’re ready to get started, I’ve pulled together hardware, fixtures, and finishes we’ve used and loved throughout our own home. Take what fits your space, leave what doesn’t, and use it as a bit of inspiration as you work through your own list of updates.
*If you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.